Public Health Policy Evaluation with Machine Learning

by Jon Scaccia February 26, 2025

How do we know if public health policies are truly effective? Whether it’s a campaign to reduce smoking, an initiative to improve maternal health, or a program to curb the spread of infectious diseases, measuring the success of these policies is crucial. Traditionally, policymakers have relied on well-established statistical methods to assess impact, but these techniques struggle to keep up with today’s complex, data-rich world.

Enter machine learning—a powerful tool that promises to revolutionize how we evaluate public health policies. But is it the silver bullet we need? While machine learning offers precise, data-driven insights, it also introduces new challenges, such as bias, privacy concerns, and lack of transparency. We use data-driven there intentionally, because we blogged before about how it’s better to be data-informed.

In this post, we’ll examine machine learning’s potential in public health policy evaluation, explore its limitations, and discuss what’s needed to ensure its responsible use.

Traditional Methods: The Strengths and Gaps

For decades, researchers have used statistical models to measure the impact of public health policies. Three widely used methods include:

• Difference-in-Differences (DID): Compares changes in health outcomes before and after a policy is implemented in treatment and control groups.
• Synthetic Control Method (SCM): Constructs a “synthetic” version of a treatment group to simulate what would have happened without the policy.
• Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD): Focuses on sharp policy thresholds (e.g., age cutoffs for vaccinations) to evaluate policy impact.

While these methods are effective, they have notable limitations. They struggle with large, unstructured datasets, require strong assumptions about cause and effect, and may not account for the complexities of real-world public health systems. This is where machine learning comes in.

How Machine Learning Improves Policy Evaluation

Machine learning brings a data-driven approach to public health evaluation. By processing massive datasets—including electronic health records, social media trends, and medical imaging—machine learning models can uncover patterns that traditional methods might miss. Here’s how it helps:

• Handling Big Data: Machine learning can analyze unstructured and high-dimensional data (e.g., medical images, free-text clinical notes, social determinants of health).
• Reducing Model Bias: Algorithms can help adjust for confounding variables, improving accuracy in policy impact assessments.
• Identifying Nonlinear Relationships: Many health policies affect populations in ways that don’t follow a simple linear pattern. Machine learning can detect these complex interactions.

For example, in a study assessing smoking cessation policies in Brazil, machine learning was used to analyze patient data and predict treatment success. The model outperformed traditional statistical methods by incorporating diverse health indicators, leading to more personalized intervention strategies.

The Challenges: Black-Box Models, Bias, and Privacy

Despite its advantages, machine learning isn’t without flaws. Here are the key challenges:

1. Lack of Transparency

Many machine learning models operate as “black boxes,” making it difficult to understand how they arrive at specific conclusions. This can be problematic when evaluating public policies, where transparency is essential for accountability. Researchers are working on methods like SHAP values (Shapley Additive Explanations) to provide insights into which factors influence model predictions.

2. Risk of Data Bias and Perpetuating Inequities

Machine learning models are only as good as the data they’re trained on. If historical data reflects health disparities (e.g., racial bias in medical treatment), machine learning can reinforce these inequities rather than address them. A multi-level data strategy that incorporates diverse and representative data sources can help mitigate bias. Tools like IBM AI Fairness 360 are also being used to detect and correct disparities in datasets.

3. Privacy and Ethical Concerns

Public health data contains sensitive information. Using machine learning to analyze large datasets raises concerns about data security, informed consent, and potential misuse. Privacy-preserving technologies such as differential privacy (used by the U.S. Census Bureau (and we hope continue to be used) and federated learning (which allows data to remain decentralized) offer ways to balance data utility with security.

What’s Next? The Future of Machine Learning in Public Health Policy

To make the most of machine learning while minimizing its risks, a balanced approach is needed. Here’s what the future could look like:

• Combining Data-Driven and Theory-Driven Approaches: Machine learning should complement—not replace—traditional statistical methods. Hybrid models that incorporate epidemiological theories can improve interpretability.
• Developing Ethical AI Frameworks: Policymakers must establish guidelines that prioritize transparency, fairness, and privacy in AI applications.
• Strengthening Interdisciplinary Collaboration: Public health experts, data scientists, and ethicists should work together to ensure that machine learning aligns with real-world needs.

Join the Conversation

What do you think about the role of machine learning in public health policy evaluation? Do the benefits outweigh the risks? How can we ensure that AI-driven evaluations promote equity and transparency? Share your thoughts in the comments or join the discussion on social media!

By integrating machine learning responsibly, we can unlock new insights that drive more effective and equitable public health policies—ultimately improving health outcomes for all.

Don’t Miss Out – Subscribe Now!

Public health needs your voice today. Join thousands of leaders already making a difference. Subscribe for free to This Week in Public Health and receive weekly updates packed with tools to drive change.
🚨 Urgency matters—take action now and share this blog to expand our reach!