Crafting the Perfect Research Question

by Jon Scaccia November 4, 2024

The Power of PICO and Beyond

When you think of scientific research, you might picture labs, data sets, or complex formulas, but there’s a step before all of that—one that’s equally important: the research question. This foundational piece of any study not only sets the course for what researchers will explore but also determines how they’ll go about investigating it. The process of formulating a strong, well-structured research question is like laying a solid foundation for a house. Without it, everything else becomes shaky and unstable.

For public health practitioners and researchers, the value of asking the right question can’t be overstated. Whether you’re investigating the effectiveness of a new intervention, tracking the spread of a disease, or exploring risk factors for chronic illness, your question frames the scope, focus, and direction of your study.

Why Does a Good Research Question Matter?

Before diving into the specifics of how to craft one, it’s essential to understand why a research question is so crucial. At its core, a well-constructed question helps:

1. Clarify Your Study Focus: A clear question cuts through the noise and distractions, allowing you to zero in on exactly what you want to investigate.
2. Design Your Methodology: It helps you select the right study design, tools, and methods.
3. Guide Data Collection and Analysis: The question shapes how you gather and interpret your data, ensuring you stay on track.
4. Identify Knowledge Gaps: A well-posed question can reveal areas that need more attention, guiding future research efforts.

For students designing a thesis or planning research studies, this initial step can be daunting but is critical to success. Without a clear, relevant question, research can quickly lose focus or, worse, fail to address the issue at hand.

Enter PICO: The Go-To Framework

If you’ve ever been in a public health classroom or worked on clinical research, chances are you’ve encountered the PICO framework. PICO is a handy tool that helps researchers organize their thoughts and formulate specific, actionable research questions.

PICO stands for:

• P – Population/Patient: Who is the study focused on? This could be a specific group of patients, a demographic, or a population experiencing a particular issue.
• I – Intervention: What is being introduced, changed, or tested? This could be a treatment, policy, or preventive measure.
• C – Comparison: What are you comparing the intervention against? This might be a placebo, standard care, or no intervention at all.
• O – Outcome: What are the expected results? Are you looking for improved health outcomes, reduced symptoms, or a change in behavior?

An example of a PICO-based question might be: In adults with hypertension (P), does daily exercise (I), compared to no exercise (C), reduce blood pressure (O)?

The beauty of PICO is its simplicity and flexibility. It’s especially effective for clinical studies, which focus on comparing interventions and measuring outcomes.

Beyond PICO: Tailoring the Framework for Different Studies

While PICO is a fantastic tool for interventional research, it doesn’t always fit every study design. Different types of research call for variations in how questions are formulated. Thankfully, over the years, researchers have introduced several frameworks to address these nuances.

Here’s a quick look at a few alternatives:

1. PEO (Population, Exposure, Outcome): This framework is useful for studies looking at risk factors or causes. It focuses on the population, their exposure to a specific factor, and the resulting outcome. For instance, In elderly patients (P), does exposure to air pollution (E) increase the risk of respiratory issues (O)?
2. CoCoPop (Condition, Context, Population): Often used in prevalence studies, CoCoPop asks about a condition, the context in which it occurs, and the population affected. An example might be: What is the prevalence of asthma (Co) in urban areas (Co) among school-aged children (Pop)?
3. SPICE (Setting, Perspective, Intervention, Comparison, Evaluation): Ideal for public health studies, SPICE introduces the “setting” and “perspective” elements to focus on where and how the intervention is applied. For example: In rural communities (Setting), from the perspective of local health workers (Perspective), how effective is mobile health technology (Intervention) compared to traditional outreach programs (Comparison) in increasing vaccination rates (Evaluation)?
4. PICo (Population, Phenomenon of Interest, Context): Frequently used in qualitative research, PICo digs into experiences and phenomena rather than interventions and outcomes. It might ask something like: In cancer survivors (P), what are the psychological experiences (I) of returning to work (Co)?

How to Choose the Right Framework for Your Study

For students or early-career researchers, choosing the right framework can feel overwhelming, but it comes down to understanding the nature of your study. Here’s a quick guide:

• Interventional studies (e.g., clinical trials): Use PICO or PICOT (with the added “T” for Time).
• Risk factor or etiological studies: Opt for PEO or CoCoPop.
• Prevalence or incidence studies: Stick with CoCoPop or PEO.
• Qualitative research: Choose PICo or SPICE.

Regardless of which framework you select, the key is to ensure your question is clear, focused, and answerable within the scope of your study. A poorly formulated question will lead to confusion, while a well-structured one can illuminate a clear path forward.

Practical Tips for Formulating Your Question

As you begin to develop your research question, keep these practical tips in mind:

1. Start Broad, Then Narrow Down: Begin with a general area of interest, then refine it until you land on a specific question.
2. Be Feasible: Make sure your question can be realistically answered within your time, resource, and methodological constraints.
3. Avoid Ambiguity: Be as clear and specific as possible. Vague questions lead to vague studies.
4. Consider Relevance: Ensure your question addresses a significant issue that’s pertinent to your field.

These guidelines streamline the process and ensure that your study adds meaningful insights to the body of knowledge in your discipline.

Read more!

Hosseini, M. S., Jahanshahlou, F., Akbarzadeh, M. A., Zarei, M., & Vaez-Gharamaleki, Y. (2024). Formulating research questions for evidence-based studies. Journal of Medicine, Surgery, and Public Health, 2, 100046.

Join the Conversation

What challenges have you faced when formulating research questions for your studies? What frameworks have you found most helpful in your research? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below or join the discussion on social media using #ResearchQuestionFrameworks.

Stay Ahead of Public Health Advances!

Get the latest scientific insights delivered straight to your inbox. Our free weekly newsletter breaks down the most important research in public health so that you can make informed decisions. Subscribe today and stay informed! Click below!