A Balanced View of Asset Limits in SNAP

by Jon Scaccia February 9, 2024

The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) provides essential support to millions of low-income households across the United States. However, the program’s asset limits — designed to target assistance to those most in need — could have a broader impact than intended, influencing participants’ financial stability and behavior.

The Urban Insitute‘s article “Asset Limits, SNAP Participation, and Financial Stability” (will download a pdf) delves deep into this topic, exploring the balance between fiscal responsibility and providing a safety net for the vulnerable.

Understanding Asset Limits in SNAP

Assets are a critical safety net for households, helping weather financial emergencies and offering a path to long-term economic stability. However, asset limits are used in programs like SNAP to ensure that benefits go to those in dire need. This means households with savings or assets beyond a certain threshold may not qualify for assistance. While these limits aim to ensure efficient use of resources, they might also discourage savings and financial planning among low-income families, potentially leading to greater long-term instability and dependency on aid.

The Impact of Asset Limits: A Closer Look

The study utilizes data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP) spanning over several years to understand how asset limits affect SNAP eligibility, asset accumulation, and the behavior of low-income households. Key findings from the study highlight:

1. Demographics of Affected Households: High-asset, low-income households tend to be older and are more likely to include an elderly adult, reflecting a lifetime’s accumulation of assets but reduced income during retirement.
2. Influence on Eligibility and Participation: Asset limits reduce the number of households eligible for SNAP, with broader implications if categorical eligibility policies are retracted. However, it’s noted that the actual participation in SNAP among those eligible but with assets over the threshold is relatively low.
3. Asset Holdings and Financial Behavior: The presence of asset limits influences the financial behavior of households, with implications for saving and asset accumulation. Notably, households in states with relaxed asset limits through Broad-Based Categorical Eligibility (BBCE) show a slightly higher likelihood of having bank accounts and emergency savings.
4. Churn and Spell Length: While more relaxed asset limits reduce the administrative churn in SNAP participation, they don’t significantly affect the overall duration of SNAP receipt. Interestingly, higher wealth and debt among low-income households are associated with shorter durations of SNAP assistance.

Balancing Act: Policy Implications and Future Directions

The article concludes that asset limits are crucial in targeting SNAP benefits but also have unintended consequences. The findings suggest that such limits might deter savings and reduce participation in mainstream financial markets, potentially leading to increased financial instability and higher program costs due to administrative churn.

The key takeaway for public health practitioners and policymakers is the need for a nuanced understanding of asset limits. Future policies might need to balance the immediate fiscal goals of asset limits with their long-term impact on household behavior and financial stability. Continued research and data-driven approaches will be crucial in crafting policies that support low-income households’ financial health and stability while ensuring the efficient allocation of SNAP benefits.

Engage with the Original Study

For a deeper understanding of the complexities and impacts of asset limits in SNAP and their broader implications on public health and policy, reading the full article “Asset Limits, SNAP Participation, and Financial Stability” is highly recommended.

Transform Information into Action – Subscribe Now!

Your key to unlocking the power of public health knowledge awaits! ‘This Week in Public Health’ is not just a newsletter; it’s a catalyst for informed action. With a focus on cutting-edge research, community health successes, and advocacy insights, each issue empowers you to make a tangible impact. Subscribe for free and turn information into action today!