When Zip Codes Predict Lives Lost: The Links Between Social Vulnerability, Race, and Police Violence

by Jon Scaccia January 15, 2025

We’ve written before about police violence.

What if where you lived determined your likelihood of a fatal encounter with the police? This startling reality is what a recent study reveals, uncovering the intersection of social vulnerability, race, and geography in shaping the tragic statistics of fatal police shootings. From 2015 to 2022, nearly 7,000 lives were lost to fatal police shootings in the United States, and this research takes a closer look at where and why these incidents occur.

The Hidden Geography of Police Violence

Researchers analyzed fatal police shootings across 32,736 zip codes using data from Mapping Police Violence and the Washington Post’s Fatal Force Database. By merging this with the Social Vulnerability Index (SVI)—a metric designed by the CDC to identify communities most vulnerable to crises—they created a powerful lens to examine the deadly interactions between police and civilians.

Their findings are both illuminating and alarming: zip codes with high social vulnerability experienced 8.3 times more fatal police shootings than those with low vulnerability. The disparities were even starker for racial minorities, with Black individuals facing a 20-fold increase and Hispanic individuals a staggering 27-fold increase in high-vulnerability areas compared to low-vulnerability ones.

What Makes a Community “Vulnerable”?

Social vulnerability encompasses factors like poverty, housing instability, unemployment, and limited access to transportation or healthcare. These conditions often overlap with racial segregation and historical inequities, creating what the study calls “concentrated disadvantage.” This complex web of systemic inequities amplifies the risks for minority communities, particularly in areas with higher crime rates and greater police presence.

Historical practices like redlining have cemented racial and economic divides, ensuring that communities of color remain disproportionately affected by poverty and underinvestment. This systemic neglect doesn’t just impact health or education—it also shapes how these communities are policed, often with devastating consequences.

The Human Cost of Social Vulnerability

To understand these numbers, let’s imagine two hypothetical neighborhoods:

• Neighborhood A is a majority-white, low-SVI zip code with steady employment, robust healthcare access, and well-funded schools. Police presence here is minimal, and fatal police shootings are rare.
• Neighborhood B is a racially diverse, high-SVI area marked by poverty, overcrowded housing, and underfunded public services. Police patrol frequently, often treating routine interactions as potential threats. Here, a minor disturbance can quickly escalate into a fatal encounter.

This stark contrast shows how the environment—not just individual behavior—shapes outcomes. In high-SVI areas, compounded vulnerabilities often make fatal police encounters more likely.

Beyond Crime: The Role of Perception and Bias

The study also highlights theories like the “minority threat hypothesis,” which suggests that police view communities of color as inherently threatening, especially in economically disadvantaged areas. These biases can lead to over-policing and more aggressive enforcement, disproportionately affecting Black and Hispanic residents.

Interestingly, even the perception of gun ownership plays a role. In areas with higher firearm access, police may be quicker to assume civilians are armed, escalating interactions unnecessarily.

What Can We Do About It?

The findings paint a sobering picture, but they also offer a roadmap for change:

1. Address Social Vulnerability
   Policies targeting income inequality, affordable housing, and access to education can reduce the disparities that fuel police violence.
2. Rethink Policing Strategies
   Enhancing police training in de-escalation, addressing racial bias, and increasing community representation in police departments are critical first steps. The use of body cameras and transparency in police actions can also improve accountability.
3. Tackle Gun Violence
   Communities with high gun access see higher rates of fatal shootings, suggesting that stricter firearm regulations and violence prevention programs could save lives.
4. Invest in Public Health Approaches
   Treating police violence as a public health issue recognizes its broader societal impact, from mental health to premature mortality. Interventions at the community level can create safer, more equitable environments.

What’s Next?

This study underscores the urgent need for further research to untangle the complex interplay of social vulnerability, race, and policing. Future work could explore interventions that reduce vulnerability, assess the effectiveness of policing reforms, and investigate the role of implicit bias in fatal police encounters.

Join the Conversation

What do these findings mean for your community? How can public health practitioners and policymakers work together to reduce disparities in policing? Share your thoughts:

• How can addressing social vulnerability improve public safety?
• What role should community members play in shaping policing practices?
• What other strategies could help reduce fatal police shootings?

Let’s work toward a future where zip codes are no longer predictors of tragedy but beacons of opportunity and equality.

Empower Your Network – Subscribe and Share!

Unlock key insights with ‘This Week in Public Health.’ Subscribe for free and share to drive change as part of a dedicated community. If you liked this blog, please share it! Your referrals help This Week in Public Health reach new readers.