When Sexual Healthcare Makes Patients Do the Work
For many trans, non-binary, and gender diverse adults, reaching sexual healthcare is only the first access hurdle. They may also have to research their own symptoms, assess whether a clinician is likely to understand them, decide what information feels safe to disclose, and sometimes educate the person providing their care.
That burden is the central finding of a qualitative UK study published in Frontiers in Public Health. Participants often knew what they needed and could identify available services. The harder question was whether those services could be trusted to respond with relevant knowledge, respectful communication and appropriate care.
The findings challenge a narrow view of healthcare access. A clinic can exist, offer free care and have open appointments while remaining functionally inaccessible to people who expect misunderstanding, invasive questions or consequences for other treatment.
Access depended on more than service availability
The researchers interviewed 19 trans, non-binary, and gender-diverse adults living in England and Scotland. Participants ranged from age 18 to their mid-60s. Most were trans masculine, 15 of the 19, and 17 reported current or past disabilities or health conditions. Sixteen had not had gender-affirming genital surgery.
The face-to-face, semi-structured interviews took place from July 2019 through March 2020. They explored participants’ experiences of sexual function, sexual problems, and support related to sex. Researchers then analyzed the interviews using a framework that defines access through five service qualities: whether care is approachable, acceptable, available, affordable, and appropriate.
Participants described experiences across general practice, sexual health clinics, gender-affirming care, nonprofit and peer-led organizations, and remote or postal services. Their accounts showed that these dimensions of access were tightly connected. A nearby service was of limited value if its staff lacked relevant knowledge. A technically appropriate clinic could still be out of reach because of distance, transportation, mobility or time constraints.
Specialist services focused on trans, non-binary and gender diverse people were generally viewed as more acceptable. Yet the few such services discussed were concentrated in cities. Some participants could travel to them, but that option depended on money, time and physical mobility.
Patients anticipated gaps before entering the clinic
Most participants did not lack health knowledge or the ability to seek care. Instead, they expected clinicians might lack knowledge about their bodies, partners or sexual practices. That expectation shaped what happened before and during appointments.
Participants searched online, consulted peers, and learned about services through personal networks. This information helped them judge whether an experience represented a health concern, identify a potentially suitable clinic, and prepare to advocate for themselves. Some entered consultations expecting to explain basic information to the clinician.
The researchers describe this preparation as a compensatory strategy. It may help a patient secure better care, but it transfers work from the service to the person seeking help. It also assumes that the person has internet access, supportive peers, time, and the ability to judge the credibility of information.
One participant seeking an STI test reported that a GP focused on the genitalia of the participant’s non-binary partner, even though the participant did not consider that information relevant to the requested urine test. Other accounts involved symptoms being dismissed, irrelevant or invasive questions, and uncertainty about whether clinicians understood trans and non-binary experiences.
Positive experiences offered a clear contrast. Participants valued nurses and doctors who listened, responded without judgment, took symptoms seriously, and sought information themselves. Self-sampling also reduced stress for one participant by allowing STI swabs to be collected without an intimate examination. These examples suggest that relatively concrete choices in communication and service delivery can change whether care feels usable.
Why combining services can weaken trust
One of the study’s most consequential findings concerned overlap between sexual healthcare and gender-affirming care. Co-locating services may appear efficient, and one participant benefited from a clinician whose expertise crossed menopause, gynecology, and gender identity care. For many others, however, shared locations or staff raised fears that information disclosed in sexual healthcare could reach gender clinicians and delay gender-affirming treatment.
Participants responded by withholding information or disclosing only what they considered necessary. Some preferred sexual health services that were clearly separate from gender services, where they felt more able to discuss their needs fully.
The study does not show that information sharing actually delayed participants’ gender-affirming care. It shows that the possibility was credible enough to change their behavior. From an access perspective, that perception matters. Patients who do not trust the boundaries between services may avoid care or give clinicians an incomplete account, even when both services are located under one roof for convenience.
This also means co-location is not inherently helpful or harmful. Its effect depends on transparency, record-sharing practices, staff behavior, and whether patients believe discussions about sexuality could influence gender-related treatment decisions.
Geography and cost narrowed the available choices
Participants described greater access to suitable sexual healthcare in urban areas. Outside general practice, they did not discuss experiences with rural sexual health services. Postal testing and other remote options helped some people, but they could not meet every need, particularly when symptoms required examination, discussion or referral.
Although UK statutory sexual healthcare does not carry a direct individual charge, access still involved indirect costs. Travel, time away from work and mobility constraints could determine whether a specialist clinic was realistically available. Long waits for gender-affirming care also led one participant to work and save for private testosterone and chest surgery.
These accounts show why counting clinics or appointments provides an incomplete measure of access. A meaningful measure is whether people can reach appropriate care, trust it enough to use it, and participate without managing preventable clinical knowledge gaps.
What This Means in Practice
- Primary care and sexual health services: Review intake questions and clinical scripts for assumptions about gender, anatomy and partners. Ask only for information relevant to the patient’s symptoms, requested test, or treatment. Offer options such as self-sampling when clinically suitable.
- Health systems operating sexual health and gender services: Explain whether staff, records, or information are shared across services. Patients need to know who can see sexual health disclosures and whether those disclosures can affect gender-affirming care. Co-location without this transparency may reduce candid discussion.
- Workforce and training leaders: Build structured learning on trans, non-binary, and gender diverse sexual health into professional development. Training should address sexual function and wellbeing, not only HIV, risk or the physical outcomes of gender-affirming procedures. Clinicians should know how to find reliable information rather than expecting patients to teach them.
- Commissioners and service planners: Assess access in terms of travel time, transport, disability access and separation or overlap with gender services. Remote services can extend reach, but planners should identify which needs still require knowledgeable in-person care.
What the study cannot tell us
This was a small qualitative study designed to explore experiences, not estimate how common each barrier is. The sample was not representative and was weighted toward trans masculine participants. Participants came from England and Scotland, with no participants recruited from Wales or Northern Ireland. The findings therefore should not be treated as a description of every trans, non-binary, or gender-diverse person’s experience.
The interviews also occurred immediately before the COVID-19 pandemic. Healthcare organizations and the wider social and political context have changed since then. Still, the interviews provide detailed evidence about how people evaluate services and adapt when they expect their needs will not be met.
The study’s strongest lesson concerns where health systems place the work of access. Participants were resourceful, selective, and often highly informed. Those strengths helped them navigate care, but they also concealed service failures. A system should not appear accessible simply because patients have learned to research, travel, self-censor, and educate clinicians in order to use it.
Build Your Public Health Issue
Tell us a little about your work, and we’ll build a personalized issue with five things worth knowing.


